Talbot - you have invented a scecnario whereby this crime was enacted by white people, and decided on an outcome.
I am unsure what the point of this is - but you have put it out there, and then systematically either attacked or ridiculed, or both, posters who are not running with this in the way you think they should.
Where you do want this to go now - since it is clearly not going the way you want it to so far?
Maybe it is time to simply accept that are not biting on your imaginary scenario, and move on to something else.